Peer Support and Fear Control: A Parallel Interaction Process in Online Breast Cancer Support Group

QIU Hongfeng, ZHOU Qianying

Chinese Journal of Journalism & Communication ›› 2021, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (6) : 98-113.

PDF(1681 KB)
PDF(1681 KB)
Chinese Journal of Journalism & Communication ›› 2021, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (6) : 98-113.
Communication Research

Peer Support and Fear Control: A Parallel Interaction Process in Online Breast Cancer Support Group

Author information +
History +

Abstract

The semi-closed online support group that cancer patients voluntarily join has become an important type of social network of patients. It is worth exploring the characteristics of group interaction and its impact on patients. In this study, 18 users of a breast cancer patient communication APP were interviewed in depth, and the data were encoded and theoretical model was constructed by doing thematic analysis. The study found that on the one hand, breast cancer patients could provide and obtain multiple peer support by telling their own experiences and reading other people’s stories, rebuilding their identity, and achieving self-empowerment in the doctor-patient relationship; on the other hand, some community members avoided discussing the issue of breast cancer recurrence, indicating that patients may be experiencing “fear control” of recurrence issues due to their high perceived threat and low perceived efficacy. Under the pressure of dominant optimistic sentiment as community norms, the recurrence issues fall into a “silent spiral”, which may block the peer support needed by relapsed patients.

Key words

breast cancer / online support group / peer support / fear control / self-identity

Cite this article

Download Citations
QIU Hongfeng , ZHOU Qianying. Peer Support and Fear Control: A Parallel Interaction Process in Online Breast Cancer Support Group[J]. Chinese Journal of Journalism & Communication. 2021, 43(6): 98-113

References

[1]
鲍雨, 黄盈盈(2014). 经历乳腺癌:疾病与性别情境中的身体认同. 《妇女研究论丛》,(2),85-95.
[2]
蔡雁, 施晓群, 金艳(2006). 乳腺癌患者术后乳房缺失心理体验的质性研究. 《中华护理杂志》, 41(2),105-108.
[3]
曹雪英, 邓暑芳, 何丽煌(2013). 病友互助护理模式对乳腺癌患者心理健康及治疗不良反应的影响. 《护理学杂志》, 28(14),23-25.
[4]
方琼英, 吴琼, 张秀玲, 马小丽(2012). 乳腺癌的流行现状分析. 《中国社会医学杂志》, 29(5),333-335.
[5]
黄宛冰, 覃湘君, 兰茂林, 程捷, 颜君(2017). 康复护理干预对乳腺癌患者上肢水肿及生命质量影响的Meta分析. 《护理学杂志》, 32(5),90-94.
[6]
黄盈盈, 鲍雨(2013). 经历乳腺癌:从“疾病”到“残缺”的女性身体. 《社会》, 33(2),185-207.
[7]
梁晓芹, 冯玉明, 王乐增(2019). 心理护理干预对乳腺癌患者术后康复及心理状态的影响. 《中国校医》, 33(07),514-516.
[8]
苏娅丽, 王丕琳, 刘均娥, 王慕兰, 薛翠翠(2014). 康复期乳腺癌患者创伤后成长及其影响因素分析. 《护理管理杂志》, 14(1),4-6.
[9]
孙可欣, 郑荣寿, 张思维, 曾红梅, 邹小农, 陈茹, 顾秀瑛, 魏文强, 赫捷(2019). 2015年中国分地区恶性肿瘤发病和死亡分析. 《中国肿瘤》, 28(1),1-11.
[10]
唐茂婷, 刘贤亮, 朱瑞雪, 吴茜, 陈蓓敏, 毛雅芬, 施雁(2018). 化疗乳腺癌患者对同伴支持的需求及与社会支持的相关性. 《中国老年学杂志》, 38(4),948-951.
[11]
吴弦光.(2017年7月). 康复与社会工作.“第七届北京国际康复论坛”会议论文.北京.
[12]
张飞艳, 宋丽华(2017). 乳腺癌患者的心理状况及其心理干预. 《中华肿瘤防治杂志》, 24(3),212-216.
[13]
Arora N. K., Finney, R. L. J., Gustafson D. H., Moser R., & Hawkins R. P. (2007). Perceived helpfulness and impact of social support provided by family, friends, and health care providers to women newly diagnosed with breast cancer. Psycho-Oncology, 16(5), 474-486.
We evaluated the helpfulness of informational, emotional, and decision-making support received by women newly diagnosed with breast cancer from their family, friends, and health care providers. Data were collected at two time points via patient surveys: baseline on an average 2 months post-diagnosis and follow-up at 5 months post-baseline. In the period closer to diagnosis, majority of the women received helpful informational support from health care providers (84.0%); helpful emotional support from family (85%), friends (80.4%), and providers (67.1%); and helpful decision-making support from providers (75.2%) and family (71.0%). Emotional support at baseline and emotional and informational support at 5-month follow-up were significantly associated with patients' health-related quality of life and self-efficacy outcomes (p<0.01). Perceived helpfulness of informational, emotional, and decision-making support provided by family, friends, and providers however significantly decreased over time (p<0.001). Cancer patients' desire significant amount of support throughout their cancer journey. Our results show that while patients receive a lot of support during the period closer to diagnosis, receipt of helpful support drops significantly within the first year itself. In order to facilitate cancer patients' adjustment to their illness, efforts need to be made to understand and address their support needs throughout the cancer experience.
[14]
Askay D. A. (2015). Silence in the crowd: The spiral of silence contributing to the positive bias of opinions in an online review system. New Media & Society, 17(11), 1811-1829.
A positive bias of opinions has frequently been identified across online review websites, suggesting that the public is making decisions based on a limited range of opinions. While scholars often attribute this bias to social loafing or self-selection, this study investigates the positive bias from the perspective of opinion expression. Drawing from the spiral of silence theory, a qualitative analysis of discussion forums reveals that fear of isolation reduces the willingness of members to voice neutral and negative reviews. Additionally, communicative affordances of the interface were found to further suppress neutral and negative opinions. These results extend the spiral of silence theory into the context of non-anonymous multichannel communication platforms and indicate the need to consider the role of communicative affordances in online opinion expression.
[15]
Bandura A. (1999). Social cognitive theory: An agentic perspective. Asian Journal of Social Psychology, 2(1), 21-41.
[16]
Brashers D. E., Goldsmith D. J., & Hsieh E. (2002). Information seeking and avoiding in health contexts. Human Communication Research, 28(2), 258-271.
[17]
Brashers D. E., Neidig J. L., Haas S. M., Dobbs L. K., Cardillo L. W., & Russell J. A. (2000). Communication in the management of uncertainty: The case of persons living with HIV and AIDS. Communication Monographs, 67(1), 63-84.
[18]
Braun V. & Clarke V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77-101.
[19]
Bricker-Jenkins M. (1994). Feminist practice and breast cancer: “The patriarchy has claimed my right breast...” Social Work in Health Care, 19(3-4), 17-42.
Breast cancer is the leading cause of death of women between the ages of thirty-five and forty-five. Women of color and lesbians are particularly vulnerable populations. In this article, a feminist social worker weaves her personal experience with breast cancer, the literature on social work and breast cancer, and her research on feminist practice to propose some guidelines for services and practice.
[20]
Cabling M. L., Turner J. W., Hurtado-de-Mendoza A., Zhang Y., Jiang X., Drago F., & Sheppard V. B. (2018). Sentiment analysis of an online breast cancer support group: Communicating about Tamoxifen. Health Communication, 33(9), 1158-1165.
A better understanding of the breast cancer online narrative is important for a clearer conceptualizing of the role of online platforms in mediating health-related support. Sentiment analysis was conducted on a breast cancer online support group regarding Tamoxifen to understand users' emotions and opinions. This analysis was then contextualized within online social support literature. Out of the 498 users, the most active users were 80% more positive than least active users, while least active users were 48% more negative than most active ones; both differences were statistically significant. The higher the stage of cancer a user had, the less likelihood that she would have posted, and if she were to post, the post would have focused on her side effects and the anxiety/sadness that tailgates those side effects. The lower the stage of cancer a user had, the more likelihood that she would have posted, additionally remained active on the forum, and encouraged more (online) social support. This finding suggests that the online support platform may provide a context that exacerbates support for like-minded users where stronger ties are created around a specific sentiment within the community with less connection from those with dissimilar sentiments to the dominant group.
[21]
Charmaz K. (1995). The body, identity, and self: Adapting to impairment. Sociological Quarterly, 36(4), 657-680.
[22]
Cohen, S., Gottlieb B., & Underwood L.G. (2000). Social relationships and health.In Cohen, S. Underwood, L. G. & Gottlieb, B. (Eds.). Social support measurement and intervention: A guide for health and social scientists (pp.3-29). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
[23]
Davidson L., Chinman M., Sells D., & Rowe M. (2006). Peer support among adults with serious mental illness: A report from the field. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 32(3), 443-450.
Peer support is based on the belief that people who have faced, endured, and overcome adversity can offer useful support, encouragement, hope, and perhaps mentorship to others facing similar situations. While this belief is well accepted for many conditions, such as addiction, trauma, or cancer, stigma and stereotypes about mental illness have impeded attempts on the part of people in recovery to offer such supports within the mental health system. Beginning in the early 1990s with programs that deployed people with mental illness to provide conventional services such as case management, opportunities for the provision and receipt of peer support within the mental health system have proliferated rapidly across the country as part of the emerging recovery movement. This article defines peer support as a form of mental health care and reviews data from 4 randomized controlled trials, which demonstrated few differences between the outcomes of conventional care when provided by peers versus non-peers. We then consider what, if any, unique contributions can be made by virtue of a person's history of serious mental illness and recovery and review beginning efforts to identify and evaluate these potential valued-added components of care. We conclude by suggesting that peer support is still early in its development as a form of mental health service provision and encourage further exploration and evaluation of this promising, if yet unproven, practice.
[24]
Dennis C. L. (2003). Peer support within a health care context: A concept analysis. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 40(3), 321-332.
[25]
Dunn J., Steginga S. K., Rosoman N., & Millichap D. (2003). A review of peer support in the context of cancer. Journal of Psychosocial Oncology, 21(2), 55-67.
[26]
Frank A. W. (1995). The wounded storyteller: Body, illness, and ethics. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
[27]
Helgeson V. S., Cohen S., Schulz R., & Yasko J. (2000). Group support interventions for women with breast cancer: Who benefits from what? Health Psychology, 19(2), 107-114.
Research on the benefits of social support groups has been inconclusive. One reason is that individual differences in intervention responses have rarely been examined. The authors determined the extent to which individual difference variables moderated the effects of an information-based educational group and an emotion-focused peer discussion group on the mental and physical functioning of women with breast cancer (n = 230). The authors administered the SF-36 (S.E. Ware, K.K. Snow, M. Kosinski, & B. Gandek, 1993), a multidimensional quality of life instrument, pre- and postintervention. Educational groups showed greater benefits on the physical functioning of women who started the study with more difficulties compared with less difficulties (e.g., lacked support or fewer personal resources). Peer discussion groups were helpful for women who lacked support from their partners or physicians but harmful for women who had high levels of support. Implications of these results for clinical interventions are discussed.
[28]
Høybye M. T., Johansen C., & Tjørnhøj-Thomsen T. (2005). Online interaction: Effects of storytelling in an internet breast cancer support group. Psycho-Oncology, 14(3), 211-220.
The internet provides new ways of forming social relationships among people with breast cancer and is increasingly used for this purpose. This qualitative study, using ethnographic case-study method, aimed to explore how support groups on the internet can break the social isolation that follows cancer and chronic pain, by analysing the storytelling emerging on the Scandinavian Breast Cancer Mailing list. Using participant observation and face-to-face or online interviews of participants, we investigated the motivations of 15 women who chose the internet to counteract social isolation after breast cancer. The results showed that the women were empowered by the exchanges of knowledge and experience within the support group. The internet was considered a means for finding ways of living with breast cancer. Our study suggests that internet support groups have important potential for the rehabilitation of cancer patients.Copyright 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
[29]
Kaufert, P. A. (1998). Women resistance and the breast cancer movement.In Lock, M. & Kaufert, P. A. (Eds.). Pragmatic women and body politics (pp.287-309). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
[30]
Kleinman A. (1988). The illness narratives: Suffering, healing, and the human condition. New York, NY: Basic Books.
[31]
Longman A. J., Braden C. J., & Mishel M. H. (1996). Side effects burden in women with breast cancer. Cancer Practice, 4(5), 274-280.
This article describes the side effects burden of 307 women who were receiving treatment for breast cancer. The study provides a description of the impact of side effects burden on adult role activities (self-help), self-care, psychological adjustment, and quality of life.Data to describe the side effects burden characteristics of 307 women receiving treatment for breast cancer were drawn from the Self-Help Intervention Project. Data were collected after medical treatment was underway and treatment-related side effects were evidenced. The impact of side effects burden on adult role activities (self-help), self-care, psychological adjustment, and life quality is described.Fatigue was the most common side effect as well as the most problematic. Number of side effects and increase in side effects were moderately correlated (P < 0.0001) in a negative direction with fatigue and depression. Self-care behaviors also were associated negatively with the extension of side effects and with fatigue and depression (P < 0.001). Psychological adjustment was associated with difficulty sleeping, anxiety, and depression. Overall life quality was noted to be negatively related to depression as was present life quality.Data support the need for clinical interventions that are individualized to women's side effects experience. Additional research is underway to test the effectiveness of the interventions specified by the overall study.
[32]
Mamykina L., Miller A. D., Mynatt E. D., & Greenblatt D. (2010, April). Constructing identities through storytelling in diabetes management. Paper presented at ACM SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. Atlanta, GA.
[33]
Mannell J., Ahmad L., & Ahmad A. (2018). Narrative storytelling as mental health support for women experiencing gender-based violence in Afghanistan. Social Science & Medicine, 214(C), 91-98.
[34]
Miles A., Voorwinden S., Chapman S., & Wardle J. (2008). Psychologic predictors of cancer information avoidance among older adults: The role of cancer fear and fatalism. Cancer Epidemiology & Prevention Biomarkers, 17(8), 1872-1879.
[35]
Noelle-Neumann E. (1974). The spiral of silence: A theory of public opinion. Journal of Communication, 24(2), 43-51.
[36]
Schulz R. & Martire L. M. (2004). Family caregiving of persons with dementia: Prevalence, health effects, and support strategies. The American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 12(3), 240-249.
[37]
Simoni J. M., Franks J. C., Lehavot K., & Yard S. S. (2011). Peer interventions to promote health: Conceptual considerations. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 81(3), 351-359.
[38]
Solomon P. & Draine J. (1995). The efficacy of a consumer case management team: 2-year outcomes of a randomized trial. The Journal of Mental Health Administration, 22(2), 135-146.
[39]
Sulik G. & Zierkiewicz E. (2014). Gender, power, and feminisms in breast cancer advocacy: Lessons from the United States and Poland. Journal of Gender & Power, 1(1), 111-145.
[40]
Van’t Riet J., Ruiter R. A., Werrij M. Q., & De Vries H. (2010). Self-efficacy moderates message-framing effects: The case of skin-cancer detection. Psychology & Health, 25(3), 339-349.
[41]
Warmerdam R., Hendricks H., & Seidel E. (1998). Assessment of rehabilitation needs in cancer patients. International Journal of Rehabilitation Research, 21(3), 247-257.
In Germany and the United States cancer patients are admitted to rehabilitation programmes after anti-cancer treatment. Such programmes do not exist in the Netherlands. This leads to the question of whether in the Dutch health care situation certain problems (impairments-disabilities-handicaps) exist in (ex)cancer patients that can be dealt with by a rehabilitation programme. Using theories on the development of health care needs of chronic patients and the WHO approach of Impairment, Disability and Handicap, a framework for a questionnaire was developed. This questionnaire used quality of life items, functional health items and items mainly from specific cancer-orientated instruments. One hundred and forty seven patients participated in the study. After the results of this phase were clear, a focus group approach combined with in-depth interviews was used to present patients with possible rehabilitation programmes. Questions were formulated verifying the nature of prior results, inquiring about specific elements and desired outcomes and about practical aspects concerning post-cancer rehabilitation. The population consisted mostly of breast cancer (69.4%) and bowel cancer patients (23.8%). Quality of life scored averagely moderate, not indicating large problems. About 26% of all respondents wanted to receive professional help; this was largely determined by perceived quality of life and level of social support. The desire for professional help concentrated significantly on role performance, cognition, control, family relations, psychologic and somatic aspects. The focus group discussion and interviews revealed that patients would prefer a rehabilitation programme focusing on reducing fatigue, reinforcing loadability, coping with social aspects, dietary aspects and finding new life targets. Quality of life seemed to be relatively high and only 26% of post-cancer patients indicated the need of rehabilitation. Related to a significantly lower quality of life score, improved physical loadability and psychosocial functioning (coping) should be the main outcomes of such a programme. Specific elements such as dietary advice and finding new life targets should, from the patients' perspective, be included.
[42]
Witte K. (1992). Putting the fear back into fear appeals: The extended parallel process model. Communications Monographs, 59(4), 329-349.
[43]
Witte K. (1994). Fear control and danger control: A test of the extended parallel process model (EPPM). Communications Monographs, 61(2), 113-134.
[44]
Witte K. (1996). Predicting risk behaviors: Development and validation of a diagnostic scale. Journal of health communication, 1(4), 317-342.
The goal of this study was to develop and validate the Risk Behavior Diagnosis (RBD) Scale for use by health care providers and practitioners interested in promoting healthy behaviors. Theoretically guided by the Extended Parallel Process Model (EPPM; a fear appeal theory), the RBD scale was designed to work in conjunction with an easy-to-use formula to determine which types of health risk messages would be most appropriate for a given individual or audience. Because some health risk messages promote behavior change and others backfire, this type of scale offers guidance to practitioners on how to develop the best persuasive message possible to motivate healthy behaviors. The results of the study demonstrate the RBD scale to have a high degree of content, construct, and predictive validity. Specific examples and practical suggestions are offered to facilitate use of the scale for health practitioners.
[45]
Witte, K. (1998). Fear as motivator, fear as inhibitor:Using the extended parallel process model to explain fear appeal successes and failures. In P. A. Andersen & L. K. Guerrero (Eds.). Handbook of communication and emotion: Research, theory, applications, and contexts (pp.423-450). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
[46]
World Health Organization. (2002). The UN standard rules on the equalization of opportunities for persons with disabilities (Report No.WHO/DAR/02.8). Retrievedfromhttps://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/69046/WHO_DAR_02.8.pdf?sequence=8&isAllowed=y
[47]
World Health Organization. (2019). Cancer: Overview. Retrieved from https://www.who.int/cancer/en/

Funding

“A study on the Impact of Public Relations Practice on the Ideological Dominance of News Media in the Era of Social Media” supported by the Fujian Social Sciences Fund(FJ2018MGCA043)
PDF(1681 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/